The Right to Be Forgotten Explained: Search Delisting, GDPR and the UK
The right to be forgotten is the common name for a person’s right, under European and UK data protection law, to ask for personal data to be erased, including asking a search engine to stop showing certain results for searches of their name. Article 17 of the GDPR is titled “Right to erasure (‘right to be forgotten’)” (GDPR Article 17). In search, it usually works as delisting: the article stays online, but a result is removed from searches for your name.
This guide explains where the right comes from, what search engines weigh, how a request to Google works and what happens if the answer is no.

Where the Right to Be Forgotten Comes From
The search engine version of the right was set out by the Court of Justice of the European Union in Google Spain (Case C-131/12), decided on 13 May 2014 (CJEU press release 70/14).
The case began with a Spanish national whose name, when searched on Google, returned links to two 1998 pages of the newspaper La Vanguardia. They contained an announcement of a real-estate auction connected with proceedings to recover social security debts he owed (CJEU press release 70/14). The Spanish data protection authority rejected his complaint against the newspaper, treating the publication as lawful, but upheld it against Google.
The Court held that a search engine operator is the controller of the processing it carries out and that it is, in certain circumstances, obliged to remove links from the results displayed for a search on a person’s name. That obligation may exist even when the publication itself is lawful and the information has not been erased from the original page (CJEU press release 70/14).
The Court also explained the time element. Even initially lawful processing of accurate data may become incompatible with the law where the data appear inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant, or excessive, in light of the time that has elapsed. Links must then be removed unless particular reasons, such as the person’s role in public life, justify a preponderant public interest in access (CJEU press release 70/14).
GDPR Right to Be Forgotten: Article 17
The GDPR later set out the right to erasure in Article 17, as Google’s own overview notes (Google Legal Help). Article 17(1) lists the grounds on which erasure applies, including where the data are no longer necessary for the purpose they were collected for, where consent is withdrawn, where the person objects under Article 21(1) and where the data have been unlawfully processed (GDPR Article 17).
The right is not absolute. Article 17(3)(a) excludes processing necessary for exercising the right of freedom of expression and information, and Article 17(3)(d) covers certain archiving, research and statistical purposes (GDPR Article 17). This is why a request about a news report involves balancing rather than an automatic outcome.
Delisting Is Not Deleting the Article
The difference between the two outcomes matters more than any other point in this guide.
| Search delisting | Removal at the source | |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | The search engine, subject to review by authorities | The publisher or website owner |
| What changes | Specific results for searches related to your name | The article or the detail itself |
| What remains | The page, and access through other searches or sites | Copies elsewhere, unless separately handled |
| Legal basis | Data protection law, as applied in Google Spain | The publisher’s policy or a separate legal claim |
Google says it will only delist content from search results for queries related to your name, and that removing material from the web can be more effective than removing it only from Google (Google Legal Help). If you want the article itself changed, start with our guide on changing or removing the article at its source.
What Google Weighs in a Request
Google describes a manual review guided by EU case law and regulators’ guidelines, and lists the factors it considers (Google Legal Help):
- Your role in public life: whether and how the information relates to a public role.
- Where the information comes from: including whether it was published by a government or as journalism, where editorial judgement is taken into account.
- How old the content is: whether the information is still relevant, and whether later events have changed its significance.
- The effect on Google’s users: for criminal convictions, Google considers whether continued display is strictly necessary.
- Truth or falsehood: Google says it is not in a good position to judge whether claims are true, so reliable evidence matters.
- Sensitive data: Google considers how sensitive or private the content is.
Google states that none of these factors is absolute and that the list is not exhaustive (Google Legal Help). A story being old, on its own, does not settle the request.
How Google’s Delisting Form Works
Google accepts requests through its right to be forgotten web form, which it links from its legal help overview (Google Legal Help). According to that overview, a request should include:
- The specific URL or URLs you want delisted.
- An explanation of how the content relates to you and why it should be delisted.
- The search query, usually your full name.
- An email address where you can be reached.
Google says it may email you for more information and will wait for your reply before proceeding (Google Legal Help). Someone may submit on your behalf only if they are legally authorised to do so, and corporations and other legal entities usually do not have rights to delist content about their corporate name.
Write the explanation around the factors above. A request that addresses your current role, what has changed since publication and any evidence, such as a later court decision, gives the reviewer something specific to weigh.
If the result is a news article and you would like the jurisdiction, URL and circumstances reviewed before submitting, that is the focus of our right to be forgotten service for news articles.
Territorial Limits of Delisting
In Google v CNIL (Case C-507/17), decided on 24 September 2019, the Court held that EU law does not currently require a search engine to carry out de-referencing on all versions of its search engine worldwide (CJEU press release 112/19). It must, however, de-reference on the versions corresponding to all Member States and, if necessary, take measures that effectively prevent or seriously discourage users in a Member State from reaching the links through non-EU versions.
The Court added that EU law does not prohibit worldwide de-referencing, and national authorities remain competent to order it after weighing the rights involved (CJEU press release 112/19).
Google says it respects the territorial scope of the relevant laws and uses geolocation signals, such as IP addresses, to restrict access to delisted URLs (Google Legal Help). For other countries, Google says a separate request should explain why that country’s law requires delisting.
Right to Be Forgotten in the UK
The UK has its own version of the regulation, the UK GDPR. Article 17 of the UK GDPR is still titled “Right to erasure (‘right to be forgotten’)” and keeps the freedom of expression and information exception in paragraph 3(a) (UK GDPR Article 17, legislation.gov.uk).
For search results, the ICO says you have a right to ask search engines to take down a result where the search is made against your name and the result is affecting your privacy rights significantly (ICO guidance on internet search results). The ICO adds that search providers do not have to remove the link but must consider your request, including whether there is a public interest in the result remaining available.
The ICO also recommends using the search provider’s own form where one exists and giving all the information requested, because the wrong form or missing information could delay or defeat the request (ICO guidance).
Check the current position before relying on older material. The ICO marks this guidance as under review following changes made by the Data (Use and Access) Act (ICO guidance).
If Your Request Is Refused
A refusal is not necessarily the end of the process. In Google Spain, the Court said that where the operator does not grant the request, the person may bring the matter before the supervisory authority or the judicial authority (CJEU press release 70/14).
- In the EU: Article 77 of the GDPR gives a right to lodge a complaint with a supervisory authority, in particular in the Member State of habitual residence, place of work or place of the alleged infringement (GDPR Article 77).
- In the UK: the ICO says that if a search provider refuses to remove a link, you can report your concern to it (ICO guidance). For data protection complaints generally, the ICO recommends raising the concern with the organisation first (ICO complaints page).
Before escalating, read the reasons given. If the refusal turns on public interest or your public role, new information about what has changed since publication is more useful than repeating the original request.
The publisher route stays open alongside any search request. If an editor has already said no, our guide on what to do when a publisher refuses to remove an article sets out the options.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is the Right to Be Forgotten in Simple Terms?
It is a data protection right to ask for personal data to be erased, which in search means asking for certain results to be removed from searches of your name. It is weighed against freedom of expression and information rather than granted automatically (GDPR Article 17).
Does a Successful Request Delete the News Article?
No. The ICO explains that search providers cannot delete information from the page where it is published, and that removing it completely requires asking the website itself (ICO guidance).
Does the Right to Be Forgotten Apply Outside Europe?
Google says it respects the territorial scope of the relevant laws and accepts separate requests explaining why another country’s law requires delisting (Google Legal Help). Do not assume the EU or UK route applies where you live.
Is This the Same as Removing Personal Information From Google?
No. Google’s personal information policies cover items such as contact details and ID numbers, while the right to be forgotten is a legal balancing exercise for name-based results. Our guide to removing personal information from Google explains those policies, and the overview of how to remove your name from Google Search compares all routes.
Considering a Request About a News Article?
If a news result appears for your name and you want to understand whether delisting, a publisher request or neither is relevant, start with a single link and a short description of the concern.
Operated by Collegium of International Lawyers LP. We are not affiliated with Google; decisions on requests are made by publishers, search engines and the relevant authorities.